Money Go Round
Magnus Wheatley writes that people (oops we mean men) jumping one AC ship to another (Surely for nothing other than money) is just fine with him. Seems to me cheapen, exploit and make an already farcical event even more so. Money, corruption, the status quo, and egos make all sport – despite our superficial enjoyment of them – often rotten and quite ugly. – tempesta.
Shady dealing and horse-trading of talent in the America’s Cup is nothing new. In fact, it’s very much the calling card of this rather unique event. The talent has always been rare, and you have to have a compelling proposition to attract the best – or a very big wallet. Those are, more often than not, mutually exclusive.
Arguably the most controversial in modern times was when the mercenary Kiwis, fresh from a dominant 5-0 victory in Auckland in 2000, jumped ship to eye-watering fortunes with the Swiss in 2003. Many of those were set for life, as were their children’s children, and land-locked Switzerland begun a two-series dominance of the America’s Cup. I don’t blame them. Time at the top of the America’s Cup is painfully short for the pros. More here.
Title inspiration thanks to The Style Council.
Dirty Money?

Benny the Bilge Rat tries to unravel a mystery. (Given the hideous amounts of corruption in the world, and pushed to new depths by the Orange Anus here in the good ol’ US of A, and with the amount of secrecy surrounding this boat, who would be even remotely surprised if there was something dirty here? The Rat makes no such inference in this article, but only an idiot – or a sailmaker – wouldn’t ask any questions)… tempesta.
Here’s something odd.
The owners of the world’s racing supermaxis all love to have their names associated with the boats they’ve spent millions to build or acquire. They’re proud to pull on a crew T-shirt at the major regattas, be pictured at the helm, and bask in the dockside attention.
All except one.
When the Australian yachtsman, Jim Cooney, sold Comanche in 2019 we weren’t told who was the legendary 100-footer’s new owner. There were persistent rumours that it now belonged to “Russian interests”, but nothing was ever confirmed.
For the next five years Comanche was campaigned by different individuals under charter or lease. The identity of the actual owner remained a mystery.
After the outbreak of the Ukraine war in early 2022 many of the Russian-owned yachts in Western ports were detained or impounded. World Sailing declared a ban that “excludes the participation of any boat owned or effectively controlled or managed by a Russian or Belarussian individual or entity.” Scorpios, anyone?
There was a scramble by the oligarchs to transfer documented ownership of their boats to non-Russian nominees in neutral jurisdictions.
Tracking those arrangements-of-convenience is difficult. The current charter of Comanche to Sydney accountant Anthony Bell for this year’s offshore season Down Under seemed an opportunity to discover more.
But, for once, Benny’s digging into the murky world of international business has yielded little in the way of substantial information.
All we have been able to confirm (from a director of the company that runs the boat), is that Comanche is owned by “a Singapore national”. No name given. We can only speculate as to why the identity of this one owner should remain secret.
There are around 3,000,000 adult Singapore nationals. Despite his congenital curiosity, your friend Benny is not proposing to contact each one of them in turn to ask whether they list a supermaxi based in Australia among their assets.

The Rat
$150,000??

Photographer Giles Martin-Raget posted this pic showing a destroyed jib on a monsterous J Class boat. People wondered how much a replacement jib would be, and I guessed that it would cost $50,000. I was quickly told by at least one sailmaker that it would very likely cost $150,000 +.
FFS! That is stupid money for one sail. Now imagine the cost of an entire inventory! Who said this sport is for the rich? They were right.
Grand Theft Boato
Anyone with even a faint regard for the principles of common fairness will be appalled by this news:
The case brought by INEOS for the return of their AC75 held by Ben Ainslie is now not scheduled to be heard by the Admiralty Court in London until January 2028. That’s six months after the America’s Cup in Naples will have concluded. It’s yet another ludicrous example of how the law’s delay can make a mockery of reality.
While the boat was moved to Naples under cover of darkness, a congested court calendar has denied INEOS anything like justice. Ainslie will have the AC75 – and all the commercial benefits that come with Cup participation – even though the court might eventually rule that he had no right to them – that, in effect, they were stolen.
The case is set down to take two weeks. In practical terms, that will be two weeks of utterly pointless argument.
Even if Ratcliffe/INEOS win, the boat itself is of no use to them because they no longer run an America’s Cup campaign. Their only consolation might be an award of costs against Ainslie, which would add some hefty financial sting to his moral defeat.
But whatever happens, this will have been a meaningless saga with no real benefit other than to the UK lawyers whose fees must already be approaching hundreds of thousands of pounds.
Bottom line: Ainslie has cynically exploited the tactic that “possession is nine tenths of the law”. That, of course, is not a watertight legal principle, but it is very difficult to overturn in practice.
Yet again, the America’s Cup shows itself to be a cesspit populated by scoundrels.

The Bosun
What’s It rate?
Leviathans

Let’s take a look at the Ultims, these leviathans of the Route du Rhum. They are so big it’s hard to turn your gaze away. I have stood beside them and wondered how on earth does a single person manage sail handling on that damn machine? As Alexia Barrier, the female skipper of IDEC Sport-CIC said. “Very slowly.”
That’s the only slow thing about these monsters. Once the sails are up they are capable of sailing at a steady 40 knots, with bursts of 50 or more. Can you imagine being all alone in the middle of a black ocean night, the jagged edges of a rising moon being filtered by passing clouds, and you are coasting along at 40 knots. Screw that for a joke. It’s all good until it isn’t.
I remember capsizing my optimist when I was 10. Getting it back upright and bailing it out cost me all I had in my arms. Now think of a sudden tropical squall coming over, aimed at you, and you have a massive carbon machine with equally massive carbon sails to deal with. It’s not going to be pretty.
For this year’s Route du Rhum there are 8 Ultims being sailed by the best of the best. Defending winner Charles Caudrelier is back with a brand new Gitana 18 (Maxi Edmond de Rothschild). It’s a foiling beast designed for pure open-ocean sailing and includes vast cantilevered Y-foils and radical new ‘A’ frame style rudders. That’s a mouthful that I will have to come back to.
Then there are the two legends. Armel Le Cléac’h and Tomas Coville. I can’t count that high so the number of circumnavigations between them is above my pay grade, but let’s just say, it’s quite a few. Le Cléac’h, winner of the 2016/17 Vendee Globe will be sailing Maxi Banque Populaire XI and Coville, there is not much more that I can say about him, will be sailing the frozen pizza boat Sodebo Ultim 3. (Frozen pizzas being how Sodebo made enough money to burn on sailboats).
Not Fade Away

Mark Chew from Southern Wooden Boat Sailing is one of our favorite people. Enjoy the lastest from him here…
Entropy is the universe’s slow exhale: the tendency of all things to loosen, mingle, and reduce to their basic components.
A drop of black ink falls into a glass of water. At first it holds its dark shape. Then it unfurls into threads, the threads become clouds, and eventually the whole glass is the same grey tint. Nothing was destroyed. The ink is all still there. But it has wandered into so many possible arrangements that it will never find its way back to being a single drop. That wandering is entropy.
Just north of Mahón on the island of Menorca, there is a small but characterful village called Es Grau. Next to the carpark at the entrance to the settlement, there is a cemetery for dead boats. Not just wooden boats but discarded, unloved and unlovely plastic craft too. There is half a Hobie 14, balanced on top of a moss covered laser.
There are a few small fishing put puts, with their engines in pieces. Small shoots of Sea Fennel seem to thrive in their bilges Each one of these craft was once new, filling its owner with the promise of adventure, or at least a basket full of white Seabream. And yet now, amongst these skeletons, there seems to be an acceptance that the slow loosening, mingling and scattering of their component pieces is OK. Read on.
Title inspiration thanks to the Stones.
Rule 69.com is For Sale!

Well, I got it started, mad e decent progress, and now it is time for some younger people who can turn this thing into what it can surely be. Rule69.com is for sale
You get the amazing url of rule69.com, a fully built website that has an excellent front page, archives, and it includes the forums, classified section, podcast setup, and is ready to take it to the next level.
The ideal candidate(s) will know how to write, have video shooting and editing skills, massive amounts of enthusiasm for the sport, and the ability to convey it all via this platform. You also get the Instagram account, and the Rule 69 Facebook page.
I started it all with Sailing Anarchy (now apparently known as Sailing Fucktards) some 26 years ago, sold that, and then eventually started this, and now it’s simply time for me to move on. I’m all outta jam.
What a great experience it has been. And don’t worry, There will be a book about as much as I can remember about everything else! It’s not an exaggeration to say that we changed the way this sport is reported, and I’ll always be insanely proud of that. But now Rule69 is ready to write the next chapter with a new crew.
We have decent traffic, a fair number of forum members, and with the right team, this place can cook. You want this smoke! Interested people can email me and I’ll be happy to discuss. – scot tempesta
Carnivàle
There is a carnival atmosphere on the docks in St Malo, France as the 115 competitors in the 13th edition of the Route du Rhum prepare to do battle with the North Atlantic. In addition to an incredible fleet of mostly highly strung racing yachts – I say mostly because there are two vintage classes there to notch the average age of the fleet up a little – there is a very large and very boisterous race village.
For those who have been to the Superbowl or Soccer World Cup, the Rd uR race village can match things, beer for beer, filterless gauloises cigarette against filterless gauloises cigarette and palpable, pure excitement. The carnival is in town and this is no cruise line. (Oops – did we picture the wrong sort of carnival? Our bad, but enjoy the pic anyway. – ed)
Race officials estimate that well over 1,000,000 people will pass through the village and gawk at the yachts while sipping coffee, enjoying boudoirs which are dipped into said coffee, and sipping a pastis with water while pondering the race program. These are not sailors; these are your average mom and pops that come from all across France to take it in. Walking the docks you may encounter a lady dressed as Mary Antoinette, or a large, muscular man carrying a tiny poodle. It’s all part of the atmosphere.
Ahead of Sunday’s start it’s fun and games (mostly), but once that start gun fires, the sailors will be sailing in the wake of a lot of history and mystery.
1990 marked two firm norms in the race. There was a distinct shift to trimarans and the size limit of 6o-feet was established, indeed two notable skippers, Bruno Peyron and Francis Joyon were excluded from the race because their boats were 65-feet overall. In typical Joyon style, and you have to love the French, he lopped off a section of his hull just days before the start and he and Bruno sailed as “pirates” meaning that they weren’t included in the official rankings, but did the race anyway.
Comanche Despoiled

Benny the Bilge Rat is affronted (i.e. pissed off).
Benny and I disagree on this. Standing on ceremony doesn’t mean much to me. They paid the money, they can call it whatever they like…
Big money and gross vulgarity often go together (witness the current tenant at the White House). But there have to be limits. A clear line of decency and good taste was crossed when the new name and livery of Comanche were revealed to the Australian media yesterday.
Gone is the supermaxi’s signature red-white-black paint job with its proud American Indian theme. That distinctive design has been central to the yacht’s identity since it was launched in 2014. But not even the iconic white feather remains.
The whole boat has been ‘skinned’ in gun-metal grey, with its new name and sponsors now proclaimed in large lettering all the way down the topsides: BELL PARTNERS LOYAL PALLAS CAPITAL. Tasteful, huh?
Yet for some reason (probably known to the tax lawyers), the registered boat name is Tribeca LOYAL. Tribeca is a local wealth advisory and investment company; Pallas Capital is a real-estate development outfit; Bell Partners is the accountancy/financial management firm run by Anthony Bell, who has chartered the boat and presumably ordered the makeover.
It’s no great sin to re-name a yacht that has little provenance, or has been significantly altered. But Comanche boasts a fabulous racing record recognised throughout the world. It should be respected. Would you re-name Dorade? Windward Passage? Intrepid? Unthinkable.
Previous charterers of the VPLP/Verdier 100-footer have recognised their sponsors – thus we had Andoo Comanche and Master Lock Comanche – but they retained the yacht’s original name and livery. No such niceties troubled Anthony Bell. All his previous boats included the word “loyal” in their names, paired with the name of whichever corporation was contributing to his costs that year. It’s all business, and in this case it’s also a boorish form of vandalism.
But there could be one saving grace. Bell never holds onto a boat for long. The old Comanche paintwork is still under that new plastic skin. Let’s hope the next custodian strips that skin away so the iconic original design can re-emerge, and the name returns.

The Rat


