
Benny the Bilge Rat has a radical new take on AC38
Imagine a baseball game in which only one player from each side is allowed to bat. Imagine a basketball game where the passing is determined by a computer program. Imagine spending at least $120 million on a team that won’t even make it to the semi-finals.
Those are the conditions under which the next America’s Cup will be contested.
It’s crazy stuff. But we are now so habituated to the extremes of AC38 that it can be a shock to pause and realise just how disconnected from the sport of sailing the Cup has become. We take things for granted that are, in truth, bizarre distortions.
The boats fly on one swing-foil using technology that would be impossible on a normal yacht. There are two parallel mainsails. The crew aren’t allowed to pull ropes or grind winches. The only person who can use their hands directly is the helmsman. Decisions on trim and tactics are governed by sensor inputs feeding their real-time data into AI.
Does that sound like sailing to you?
The class rules for the Cup boats are now so dominated by technology that you have to wonder why they bother with having any humans aboard. But that gave me an idea. Why not dispense with the boats instead?
Every team already has a sophisticated simulator set-up. Let’s make the America’s Cup a computer game contest and save everyone truckloads of time and money.
Each syndicate would register the predicted performance data of their best AC design. Variables such as wind strength and direction, tide, and sea state are dialled into the race algorithm from day to day. Teams then match-race each other in linked simulators.
Consider the advantages:
- No team has to build a physical boat – a huge cost saving.
- There would be no need for crews to wear those wanky crash helmets and auto-inflating life jackets.
- There would be minimal TV coverage costs. The networks could just take a direct video feed from the simulation computer screen.
- The event would be 100% eco-friendly, doing away with all those gas-guzzling chase boats, cranes, helicopters, etc.
- There would be no event hosting fees, or the costs of building team bases.
You think old Benny is joking? Maybe not. If the event continues on its current trajectory a boat-free Cup could be the next logical step.

The Rat






